Noah Smith, Columnist

The NIMBY Backlash Against Amazon’s HQ2

Even factoring in the tax breaks, New York and Virginia will still benefit from Amazon’s expansion.

Prime real estate.

Photographer: Bloomberg/Bloomberg
Lock
This article is for subscribers only.

Splitting Amazon’s second headquarters between Queens and the Virginia suburbs of Washington was probably not the best decision from a social perspective. Added traffic will strain already crowded local infrastructure, and New York and Washington are already highly productive cities with thriving technology economies. For the country as a whole, Amazon’s decision represents a missed opportunity.

That said, critics of HQ2 go too far when they paint the investment as a disaster for local residents. The backlash has been immediate, with some community groups vowing to fight the expansion. The objections can be grouped into three basic categories, neatly summarized in a series of tweets from Representative-elect Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, whose district includes part of Queens.